Michele Schuler
A cedar bench beside calm blue-gray harbor water, with late-autumn greenery and a wooded residential shoreline across the inlet in Winslow.

A Buyer's Read on Winslow's Sales, Supply and Price per Foot

November 19, 2026

In the first ten months of 2026, Winslow had more home sales than any other part of Bainbridge Island. At the end of October it also had the island's thinnest supply. Its price per square foot, meanwhile, was the lowest of the island's sub-areas. If you are choosing between a home within walking distance of the ferry and one farther out, those three figures say what being in Winslow is worth. It buys you depth of market, not a higher price per foot.

Winslow is where Bainbridge homes actually trade

The October 2026 figures from Realogics Sotheby's International Realty's market insights, which are drawn from NWMLS data, divide the island into areas that can be compared directly.

Area, October 2026 Months of supply Homes sold Jan–Oct 2026 Avg price per sq ft Avg days on market
Winslow 2.1 103 $522 55
North Bainbridge 2.2 88 $613 67
West Bainbridge 2.9 86 $534 73
South Bainbridge 4.0 85 $611 35
Island waterfront 3.2 50 $866 63
Bainbridge Island overall 3.0 389 $566 48

Winslow's 103 sales from January through October 2026 were up 25.6% from the same period in 2025. That was the most of any area on the island, and roughly a quarter of the island's 389 sales. Its 2.1 months of supply in October was down 39.1% from a year earlier, while supply across the island as a whole rose to 3.0 months over the same period.

Speed is a different story. Winslow listings that sold in October averaged 55 days on market, which is slower than South Bainbridge's 35 days. Winslow leads on how many homes sell. That gives a buyer more recent sales to compare against and gives a seller more comparable sales to price from, so a Winslow valuation rests on more evidence than a valuation in a part of the island with fewer sales.

The walk to the ferry doesn't show up in the price per foot

Winslow's October average of $522 per square foot was the lowest on the island. That is about $90 below both North Bainbridge at $613 and South Bainbridge at $611, and well under the island-wide figure of $566.

Part of the gap is about what kind of homes are for sale. Of the 13 condos listed on the whole island in October, 9 were in Winslow. Winslow's 27 active listings were 13 single-family homes, 5 land parcels and 9 condos. North and West Bainbridge had no condos listed at all. Outside Winslow, the inventory leans almost entirely toward single-family homes and land, so a per-foot price there is set by a different kind of property.

The month's headline average needs the same care. Winslow's average sale price in October was $1.3 million, up 78.9% from October 2025. That figure comes from eight sales. With that few, one or two larger homes closing in a single month can move the average that much, while the price per square foot rose just 2.8% over the same year. When comparing Winslow with the rest of the island, the year-to-date sales count and months of supply are steadier figures than any one month's average.

Bainbridge buyers have not been paying more per foot to live near the ferry. They have been buying there more often.

More neighbors are coming to the same streets

Winslow's resale market is about to get new housing alongside it. In June 2025, the City Council directed that the island's planned housing growth be concentrated in Winslow rather than spread into neighborhood centers, the Bainbridge Island Review reported. An earlier proposal to add smaller-scale housing in places such as Rolling Bay and Lynwood Center was dropped after public pushback, the Review reported in December 2025. The council has set public hearings on the Comprehensive Plan and the Winslow Subarea Plan for November 24 and December 8, and it is expected to vote December 8, according to the Review's November 11 report. The same report said city staff had logged about 1,500 comments specific to the two plans, drawn from more than 10,000 received since January 2025.

Two named projects show what this looks like on the ground. Housing Resources Bainbridge completed its Ericksen Community in July 2026. It has 18 affordable rental homes, 12 one-bedroom and six three-bedroom, near Ericksen Avenue NE and Knechtel Way NE.

The second is planned for 625 Winslow Way E, the city-owned former police station site, with the Low Income Housing Institute as developer. In September 2026, the council authorized a memorandum of understanding with LIHI and an application for a state grant for a proposal of about 70 units. Funding is projected by May 2027, with construction running from January 2028 to completion in July 2029, according to the Review's September 24 report. If you buy near that stretch of Winslow Way this winter, the projected schedule puts about 18 months of construction there starting in January 2028.

The ferry behind the numbers

The Washington State Department of Transportation calls Seattle–Bainbridge its busiest walk-on route. Washington State Ferries' 2026 service contingency plan keeps the route at two boats. The terminal's overhead passenger walkway has been replaced with a wider structure built to current seismic code.

The sailing schedule itself is being rewritten. WSDOT's Seattle–Bainbridge schedule study found that outdated schedule assumptions contribute to recurring delays. It counted 36 schedule resets on the route in July 2025 and targets new schedules for fall 2027. If you plan to walk on most weekdays, judge a Winslow address by the walk to the dock rather than by one departure time, because the departure times will change in about a year.

Weighing a Winslow address against the rest of the island

The October figures describe two different purchases. On the north, south and west ends, buyers paid more per square foot for single-family homes and land, in areas with fewer sales to measure against. In Winslow, they paid less per foot to buy into the island's busiest resale market, within walking distance of the state ferry system's busiest walk-on route, and in the part of the island where the council has chosen to add housing.

Questions buyers are asking about Winslow this winter

Are Winslow homes cheaper than the rest of Bainbridge? Per square foot, yes, for October 2026: $522 in Winslow against $566 island-wide. Winslow's listings include most of the island's condos, so its per-foot figure reflects a different mix of homes than the north, south and west ends.

Is there much to choose from right now? Winslow had 27 active listings in October 2026, including 9 condos. With 2.1 months of supply, that was the tightest inventory on the island.

Is the Seattle–Bainbridge ferry schedule changing? WSDOT is rewriting the Seattle–Bainbridge sailing schedule and aims to put the new one in place in fall 2027.

If you are comparing a Winslow condo with a house farther out on the island, The Schuler Team can walk you through the Winslow sales behind these figures and the walk to the dock from any address you are considering. Winslow owners can start with a private home valuation built on the same sub-area data.

Work with

Whether buying or selling, Michele and her team deliver unmatched service, helping you find your dream home or maximize your property’s value. With a focus on building lifelong relationships, we make your real estate journey seamless and rewarding. You’re more than a transaction – you’re family. Let’s connect and get started today!

Follow Us